Amana vs Goodman Air Conditioners: Making the right choice for your home

If you are considering investing in an air conditioner and have narrowed down your brand options to Amana and Goodman, it will help to compare the two.

There are so many air conditioner brands on the market that it can be difficult to determine which one can offer you what you want in a cooling and heating system. It can be particularly difficult to decide between bigger, more popular brands.

Amana and Goodman are two such brands and with both being under the umbrella brand, Daikin, deciding which one is better for your home can be tough.

Looking at both brands individually can give you a better idea of what to expect from each one’s air conditioning systems.

Goodman and Amana air conditioners compared

Goodman and Amana are both owned by Daikin, but that does not make their air conditioning products, and what they offer, the same. They are distinct brands with their own product lines and features

If you are shopping for an air conditioner and have narrowed down your search to either an Amana or Goodman air conditioner, then the one that is the best investment for you will depend on your specific needs in an air conditioning system for your home.

These brands are different and when making your choice, it will be guided by what suits you.

Amana vs Goodman air conditioners

Of the units that Daikin, Amana, and Goodman produce, the variable speed air conditioner is no longer available from Goodman and in the models that are the same, Goodman is the least expensive, offering customers more options.

Not only are you getting the same equipment from Goodman at a lower price compared to Amana, but Goodman air conditioners can be installed by a greater range of technicians, meaning that installation quality varies.

Overall Goodman is one of the bestselling AC brands for its good quality and affordable prices. Amana is ranked number 10 in the ranking of Best HVAC Companies of 2022 and Goodman has beat it, securing the third position.

Amana units are best suited to homeowners who are shopping for a high-quality system with a good warranty, however, it will not be the best option for budget shoppers who may find them expensive.

Amana is also not for those who want the highest SEER rating or who want to transfer the warranty when they sell their home, Goodman, on the other hand, is best for shoppers with a limited budget looking for quality and for those who seek a warranty for the unit.

Goodman is also not ideal for homeowners looking for maximum SEER ratings and for those who want a quiet operating system.

Amana AC units Goodman AC units
#10 in Best HVAC companies #3 in Best HVAC companies
More expensive More affordable
Quieter units Louder units
Not transparent about costs Transparent about costs
SEER ratings from 14 SEER ratings from 17

Costs of Amana and Goodman air conditioners

Amana is noted for not listing their prices online, but do cite factors such as weather, construction type, and the age of your home and existing ductwork as influences in the final cost of purchasing and installing their units.

Reviewers claim that Amana prices are cost-competitive, with installation being pricier than other brands. The higher cost may be justified by the added features and technology

Goodman air conditioners are generally more cost-effective than Amana, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious consumers. Goodman units can cost you between $3 000 and $4 200, on average including installation.

The company refers customers to a local Goodman dealer and does not provide them with exact prices of air conditioners.

Features of Amana and Goodman air conditioners

Goodman air conditioners have respectable Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) ratings from 24.5 and 17, while Amana is rated between 24.5 and 14.

Three of Amana’s units are compatible with the ComfortNet Communications technology, which allows units to communicate with the smart thermostat and make minor adjustments to minimise the energy output.

Goodman air conditioners are not as technologically advanced as those of Amana, but are still regarded as the most reliable between the two.

Amana units are heavy-gauged, galvanised steel enclosures with powder-paint finishes and Goodman units have 500-hour spray-salt tested cabinet finishes.

Amana and Goodman warranties

Goodman air conditioners come with two-year unit replacement and 10-year limited warranties on their parts.

Goodman will replace the unit if it fails under certain circumstances within two years of purchasing it and replace certain broken parts within 10 years.

While Goodman offers warranties, they may not be as extensive as those offered by Amana. Amana, on the other hand, has one of the best standard warranties in the industry.

Amana typically offers longer and more comprehensive warranties compared to Goodman. This can be an important factor for consumers looking for extended coverage.

Base models are covered for a limited 10-year warranty on parts and two-year replacement warranty for compressor failure.

Premium models have a lifetime unit replacement warranty for compressor failures, but they are not transferable to new homeowners.

Leave a Comment